Court Rejects Billionaire's Bid to Obtain Milberg Weiss Work Product
CA shareholder Wyly had sought internal documents to support claim that settlement did not adequately account for company fraud
A Manhattan appeals court has rejected a billionaire investor's bid to obtain the work product of three plaintiffs firms, led by Milberg Weiss, which he claims settled a class action against software maker CA Inc., for too little.
Sam Wyly, a major CA shareholder, had sought internal documents from Milberg Weiss; Stull, Stull & Brody; and Schiffrin Barroway Topaz & Kessler to support his claims that the 2003 settlement they negotiated, valued at $134 million, failed to adequately account for fraud at CA, which ultimately landed top executives -- including CEO Sanjay Kumar and general counsel Steven Woghin -- in jail.
But in a decision issued Thursday, the Appellate Division, 1st Department, ruled that Wyly, as an absent class member in the CA suit, did not have the same right to lawyers' files as a client in a traditional "bipolar" attorney-client relationship.
In a unanimous decision written by Justice Eugene Nardelli on behalf of a panel that also included Justices Richard T. Andrias, John W. Sweeny and Bernard J. Malone, the court said the Court of Appeals' 1997 decision in Sage Realty Corp. v. Proskauer Rose, 91 NY2d 30, which held that clients are entitled to all of their attorney's work product, did not apply to absent class members.
"Sage Realty ... involved an attorney-client relationship in the traditional sense, in that the single voice of a client governs, among other things, the lawyer's conduct; the direction of a case, including any decision on when, if, and under what terms it should be settled; and the attorney's continued employment," Justice Nardelli wrote in Wyly v. Milberg Weiss, 104553/05.
"In contrast," he continued, "it has been observed, by courts and commentators alike, that the relationship between appointed counsel and an absent member in a class action differs fundamentally from that found in the traditional relationship."
The panel said absent class members were entitled to some of the benefits of an attorney-client relationship, such as privileged communications with class counsel, but had no right to direct the course of litigation. The court noted that Wyly had been free to hire his own lawyer in the CA class action, though his role still would have been limited, or opt out of the class action altogether.
The court also said Wyly had not sufficiently shown why he needed access to the lawyers' files.
Nardelli wrote that Wyly appeared to be using the state court proceeding as a "fishing expedition" for evidence that might support his ongoing battle in federal court to have the CA settlement vacated.
Last month, Wyly also filed a legal malpractice suit in Manhattan Supreme Court against Milberg Weiss and the other two class action firms in the CA case. In that suit, Wyly alleges the firms fraudulently induced class members to participate in an inadequate settlement that still paid $40 million in legal fees.
Wyly's lawyer, William Brewer of Bickel & Brewer, Thursday said his client was on firm legal ground bringing a legal malpractice case as class member and would be able to obtain the documents he sought in the course of that case. But Brewer said they would nevertheless appeal the Appellate Division's decision because it was "bad law" that allowed class action lawyers to act against the interests of class member.
Milberg Weiss, which did not respond Thursday to an e-mail request for comment, and the other firms appeared pro se.
* * * *
The below found:
- Goldman Sachs and the Financial Crisis - NY Times
Click over to review their super-slick annotated document diving tool, with the full Senate Subcommittee report. Very, very cool.
- SEC and Stanford, Goldman and Wells, Murdoch's Personal Feuds -- CJR
Why didn’t Goldman Sachs disclose to investors that it had received a Wells notice from the SEC?
- Eight Years In The Wasteland -- TPM
Riding high on the Goldman litigation, it is worth recalling that the SEC can't exactly crow about an unblemished enforcement record. Recall the R. Allen Stanford case wherein the agency was aware of fraudulent activities dating back to at least 1997 but took just shy of 10 years to act on that knowledge.
- Report: AIG Probe Likely Wrapping Up Without Criminal Charges -- TPMMuckraker
Seriously? No... Seriously?
- Thin Ice - The man behind WikiLeaks has some allegations -- CJR
The WikiLeaks surveillance drama rolls on.
- S.E.C. Said to Face Wider Porn Problem - DealBook Blog - NYTimes.com
Wait... The SEC already had a "WIDE" porn problem?
- U.S. accuses ex-Madoff exec with broad role in fraud -- TPM News Pages
It's been a bit quite on the Madoff front lately, almost as quite as this here blog (I been busy, y'all). So let's get things rolling again with this report on the fraud-related arrest of Daniel Bonventre, former Director of Operations of the Madoff firm.
- Bethany McLean on Goldman Sachs - Vanityfair.com
Enron's bane takes on Goldman Sachs. Quite a view into the culture of the real "smartest guys in the room."
- Bernie Madoff Gets a Christmas Gift: A Beating - Gary Weiss
All I can say is that if Bernie Madoff got the injuries they say from falling out of bed, it must have been the top bunk...
- Pete Sessions To Allen Stanford: 'I Love You And Believe In You' - TPMMuckraker
Sit Allen may be behind bars, but his political ties are still under investigation.
- Apple Gestapo: How Apple Hunts Down Leaks - Apple Worldwide Loyalty Team - Gizmodo
Sounds like a fund day at the office... Worth a click through just for the tasteless Indiana Jones-themed pic.
- Rothstein Arrested By FBI On Racketeering Charge | TPMMuckraker
Formal complaint filed.
- Firms Cleaning Up Madoff Mess Are Raking In the Cash -- Daily Intel
Welcome to the Madoff Stimulus package - MARP, let's call it for fun. Personally, I smell Socialism!
- American Taxpayers Admit Secret Bank Accounts; IRS Forgives - Career Management - fins.com
Are we not merciful?
- Spitzer draws line between policy, personal ethics - The Boston Globe
Well, he would have to wouldn't he.
- Hong Kong Is New Target of U.S. Crackdown on Taxes - Bloomberg.com
OECD standards are coming to Hong Kong, but not before several active investigations bear fruit.
- Ex-UBS client gets prison term for tax evasion - FT
Robert Moran, fancy boat broker, is currently wishing he banked somewhere else. Two months in prison for his trouble and this is considered lenient.
- Litigation Governance: Taking Accountability Seriously - Securities Law Prof Blog
by John C. Coffee Jr., Columbia Law School. Looks like a fascinating piece, but then I've got a soft spot for tort law.
- Security expert eyes political run - Billing Gazette
So is it Governor or Senator for Livingstone? And who are these folks compelling him to run. His campaign website was registered by Executive Action, LLC. Not exactly a "Draft Livingstone" campaign, there. And it was registered back in July of '09, so I don't know why Livingstone is describing it as "sudden." Perhaps he means that he was suddenly outed. In any case, this is shaping up as a race to watch in 2012. And if he really is pondering a run for the senate, Livingstone might want to pick up http://livingstoneforsenate.com, which is currently ripe for the squatting.
- Exhibits for the Office of Inspector General Report - Investigation of Failure of the SEC to Uncover Bernard Madoff's Ponzi Scheme
If you had a hankering to examine the exhibits from the SEC's recently released Madoff-FAIL report, you can now go nuts.
- Feds Missed Galleon Warning Signs - Newser
I know this comes as quite a shock to you...
- Seven members of House defense subcommittee scrutinized by ethics investigators - washingtonpost.com
- Madoff Trustee Advances $534 Million to Customers - Bloomberg.com
1,558 Madoff victims will see a chunk of this change. Keep in mind that the documented losses are somewhere in the neighborhood of $21 billion - with about 16,000 claims filed.
- Company Forgets Court Date, Loses $1.26 Billion in Default Judgment
Looks like Pepsi failed to challenge, may have to eat judgment. Legal secretary Kathy Henry, who set aside the notification about the suit in favor of meeting planning is probably, like, really embarassed. Pepsi has filed a motion to vacate. Not Kathy Henry's desk, mind you. With the court. About the judgment. The one and a quarter billion dollar judgment.
- Madoff friend, Picower dead, found in pool - Reuters
Jeffery Picower was listed recently as one of America's 500 Wealthiest Individuals. He was more notable for having been a close confidant of the Madoffs - and one who appeared to come out ahead even as the Madoff fraud unravelled - like $7 billion ahead. Madoff estate trustees had been pursuing this lucre on behalf of agrieved investors. Picower was found dead over the weekend, drowned at the bottom of his swimming pool. While the circumstances might lead one to believe the incident a suicide, authorities are currently calling it a drowning.
- Market Street Says Google Leaker Is No Longer An Employee
Market Street tipster watch - names are named? But which one? Galleon investigators want to know.
- Roomy Khan: Informant In Galleon Insider Trading Scandal REVEALED - HuffPo
Roomy, you didn't!
- Kroll to launch new credit rater - The Deal
Not much new here, other than projections of a first Q 2010 start date for the new firm. Click on through to the underlying FT article for more color.
- Jury's $1.8 million verdict a call for privacy rights -- Chicagotribune.com
The Lawyer: Lewis Greenblatt, "a Chicago lawyer who has represented North American for more than 30 years." The Investigators: "Probe International, a company that he and North American had used before."
- Dad’s Dumpster Dive Led to $1.8M Win in Phone Records ‘Pretexting’ Case
Pretexting and bad P.I. practices leads to $1.8 Million privacy rights verdict against North America Corp., who couldn't look more scummy based on the facts in this case. Questions: Who was the Chicago lawyer that set up NAC with the P.I. firm in question, and what firm was it?